Arguments about arts education often end up in the same place: does music or painting make children better at math and reading? In Houston, a lottery made it possible to test that question properly, and the answer was not a simple yes or no.

A program with more schools than places

The Houston Arts Access Initiative, which the researchers describe as a collective effort to restore arts education through community partnerships, launched in 2013 and brought in its first schools for the 2015–16 school year. More schools wanted in than the program could serve. According to the full research report, published in February 2019, the program’s backers “agreed to randomly allocate participation among 42 schools.”

The schools were first grouped into matched pairs with similar students, grade levels, arts resources and test results. Then a lottery decided which school in each pair got the program. That design matters. In most studies of arts education, the schools that offer more arts may already differ from those that don’t. Here, chance made the decision, so the two groups started out largely alike.

The Artful Parent

Family-life ideas and sharp reads, in your inbox.

The study followed 10,548 students in grades 3 through 8.

What the arts schools got

The 21 schools that won the lottery averaged about 10 arts experiences over the school year, roughly five more than the comparison schools. These included teaching-artist residencies, in-school performances, after-school programs and field trips, spread across dance, music, theater and visual arts. Theater made up more than half of the experiences. Schools put up their own money, which the Houston Endowment matched dollar for dollar. Together that came to an average of $14.67 per student per year.

What changed

Writing in Brookings, the study’s authors, Daniel Bowen of Texas A&M University and Brian Kisida of the University of Missouri, set out the main results.

Students in the arts schools saw “a 3.6 percentage point reduction in disciplinary infractions,” meaning fewer of them got into trouble at school. Their standardized writing scores rose by about 13% of a standard deviation.

Student surveys showed a social effect too. Students with more arts experiences reported an 8% of a standard deviation increase in compassion for others. They were more interested in how other people felt, and more likely to want to help someone being treated badly.

Among elementary students, who made up 86% of the sample, the arts also increased school engagement and college aspirations.

What didn’t

The math, reading and science scores did not shift. In the authors’ words, they “generally did not find evidence to suggest significant impacts on students’ math, reading, or science achievement.”

That result cuts two ways. Supporters of arts education sometimes claim that music or drama will lift test scores across the board, and this study does not back that up.

But the opposite worry, that time spent on the arts comes at the expense of core subjects, did not hold up either. “It seems intuitive that if you’re spending more time in the arts that you may be spending less time in reading and math,” Bowen said, as quoted in Education Week. The report found that the extra arts did not appear to harm students’ progress on the state tests.

Looking beyond test scores

The authors argue that arts programs are often judged on the wrong measures. Arts education has been squeezed in many US schools, they write, a trend “primarily attributable to the expansion of standardized-test-based accountability.” The outcomes most closely tied to what the arts set out to teach, they argue, “extend beyond commonly reported outcomes” such as math and reading scores, and data on social and emotional benefits “are not widely collected.”

The limits

The study has clear limits. It covered the program’s first two years, so it cannot say whether the effects last. Participation was voluntary, so every school was led by a principal who had chosen to sign up. And because each school picked its own mix of programs, the report says the researchers could not tell which parts made the difference. Kisida, as quoted in Education Week, described that trade-off of large experiments: “we’re not especially informed within the ‘black box’ as we call it.”

Still, it was a randomized test, run in ordinary public schools. The arts in Houston did not raise math scores. They did change how children behaved, how they wrote and how they said they felt about other people.