How common is it for a grown child to go quiet on a parent? Common enough to touch roughly one father-child relationship in four, according to 24 years of interviews from a long-running national survey.
The analysis comes from sociologists Rin Reczek, Lawrence Stacey and Mieke Beth Thomeer, published in the Journal of Marriage and Family. Counting from age 15 on, 26 percent of the children in their data went through at least one period of estrangement from their father. With mothers, it was about 6 percent.
The second finding is the gentler one. Most of those rifts did not last, at least in the short term. Of the people who had been estranged from a father and were interviewed again, 69 percent were no longer estranged at a later interview. For mothers, it was 81 percent.
The Artful Parent
Family-life ideas and sharp reads, in your inbox.
The data come from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1979, a national survey that began with Americans born between 1957 and 1964. From 1994, the children of the women in that study were interviewed in their own right once they turned 15, every two years, and from 2010 every four years for those over 30. By 2018 they ranged from 15 to 46. In all, the researchers worked with about 8,500 mother-child relationships and about 8,100 father-child relationships across 13 rounds of interviews. This summary was put together by an editorial team from the published paper, and it offers no diagnosis of any family.
Estrangement, by the survey’s yardstick
At each round, the respondents said how often they saw each parent, how often they were in touch by phone, card, letter, email, video call or text, and how close they felt. In this study, “estranged” covered two situations. One was seeing and talking to a parent no more than about once a year, however close the child felt. The other was seeing and talking to them no more than several times a year while feeling no better than “fairly close.”
The authors counted that second group on purpose. Some families live near one another and cross paths at church or at family gatherings, so contact alone can hide a relationship that has gone cold.
That choice pushes the headline numbers up. Counting contact alone, the share for fathers fell to roughly one in five, and the share for mothers to about 4 percent. Something else may push them down: children who never reported on a parent were left out, and the authors think they may well have been on poor terms, so their figures may run low.
The years around twenty-three
On average, the first estrangement from a father came at about 23, and from a mother at about 26. The authors tie that timing to the transitions of early adulthood: college, full-time jobs, parenthood, marriages and sometimes divorces.
Adult children who had been married and then divorced were more likely to become estranged from either parent than those who had never married. Having children of their own went with a lower risk of estrangement from fathers, though not from mothers.
In the father data, the largest association of all was whether the father still lived with the child’s mother. Where he did, the risk was far lower. Parents who worked full time rather than not at all also went with lower risks, as did mothers who were older when the child turned 18 and fathers with at least some college.
In the raw figures, daughters were somewhat more likely than sons to have been estranged from their father, 28 percent against 24 percent. That gap was no longer statistically significant once the researchers adjusted for the circumstances of the children and their fathers. With mothers it went the other way: sons and daughters looked alike in the raw figures, and only once the researchers adjusted for the circumstances of the children and their mothers did daughters emerge as the less likely of the two to become estranged.
Black and Latino adult children were more likely than White adult children to be estranged from their fathers. In the models that took gender and birth year into account, Black adult children were less likely to be estranged from their mothers. Gay, lesbian and bisexual adult children were more likely than heterosexual ones to be estranged from fathers, with no statistically significant difference for mothers.
The authors read these gaps as the work of larger forces. In their account, mothers are expected to do most of the raising, while discrimination, barriers to work and schooling, and incarceration rates have strained many Black and Latino fathers’ ties with their children. They also point to fathers who react badly when a child comes out.
Why any one relationship came apart is outside what this study measured. That question, from the child’s side, is the subject of our earlier piece on why grown children pull back from a parent.
The coming back
For any parent reading this, what happened next may matter most.
The researchers looked at everyone who had been estranged and was interviewed again at least once afterward, about 2,300 people in the father group and about 450 in the mother group. Roughly seven in ten of those estranged from a father, and eight in ten of those estranged from a mother, were no longer estranged by a later round. Those figures may well be low, the authors note, since people on bad terms with a parent may be less likely to keep answering the survey. And while estrangement itself varied by gender and race, its ending did not: there were no statistically significant differences by gender, race or birth year.
“Ended” here has a modest meaning. A rift counted as over once a later interview found the person seeing or talking to the parent more often, or feeling closer, enough to fall outside the definition. The study measured contact and closeness, so it cannot say whether anyone apologized or forgave. The authors themselves describe “most adult children reconciling their relationships, especially with their mother and at least in the short-term,” and other research they cite describes estrangements that go on and off again.
It is also one side of the story. Every report of contact and closeness here came from the grown child; the analysis did not use parents’ own accounts. Earlier work the authors cite, which asked mothers aged 65 to 75 in the Boston area, put 11.5 percent of mother-child ties in the estranged range. That work used a different group, a related but not identical measure and the mother’s vantage point, so the two numbers do not line up neatly. The authors note that adult children are more likely to be the ones who start low or no contact, and so may be more likely to report it.
Every family in these figures traces back to a mother born between 1957 and 1964. That makes this a portrait of one generation’s grown children, which the authors acknowledge may not reflect all young American adults. They also note that their definition of fatherhood may be narrow. A stepfather or another father figure who raised a child may not be captured, and the authors suspect estrangement rates would look different if those relationships were counted.
A father reading the one-in-four figure learns how often the distance turned up across thousands of families, and nothing about his own daughter. A grown child’s divorce, a parent with no job and the rest travel with estrangement in these data, but the study cannot show that any of them causes it.
If a rift with a parent or a grown child is weighing on you, a family therapist who can talk with both of you is the place to take it.
Going quiet on a parent, then, is common in these families. Among those who were interviewed again, it usually did not stay that way.