Your daughter calls on a Sunday afternoon. “Quick question. We’re looking at two daycares, and I can’t decide.” Before she’s finished describing the second one, you’ve told her what you think of both, what you think of daycare in general, and what her grandmother did in 1979.
She thanks you. She doesn’t ask again.
Most parents would like to be the person their grown kids turn to when they’re stuck. It’s natural to want that. You’ve got decades of experience, and some of it is useful.
The Artful Parent
Family-life ideas and sharp reads, in your inbox.
Plenty of adult children don’t ask for advice for reasons that have nothing to do with you. They have partners, friends, and coworkers to talk to, and a lot of growing up involves figuring things out alone. But sometimes small habits make asking feel like more trouble than it’s worth. Here are seven to let go of, and what to try instead.
1. Jumping in before they’ve finished
Back to the daycare call. Your daughter had only described half the situation when the answers started coming.
It’s often a sign of eagerness to help. But if you answer before you’ve heard the whole question, your advice may miss what matters most to her, like the cost, the commute, or the teacher her son already loves.
Try waiting until she’s done, then asking one question before giving any opinion: “What’s making it hard to choose?”
2. Questioning the decision instead of answering the question
She asked which daycare. You answered whether she should use daycare at all.
When an adult child asks a specific question, they’ve often already made the bigger decision. Reopening it can make them feel they have to defend their life every time they ask for help with a detail.
Answer the question they asked. If you have concerns about the bigger picture, keep them for another time, and only if they invite it.
3. Sounding certain about things that have changed
“Just walk in, shake the manager’s hand, and leave your résumé.” “Lock in a 30-year mortgage and you’ll be fine.” “Let the baby cry it out, we all did.”
Some advice holds up for decades. Some doesn’t. Job searches, housing, technology, and parenting guidance can look very different now than when you were their age.
You can share your experience without claiming it still applies: “This is how it worked for us, though I know a lot has changed. How does it work now?” Being curious about what’s different can make your view more useful, not less.
4. Saying it again, and again
You told your son you didn’t think he should buy the car. You mentioned it again on the phone. Then in an email with an article attached.
Repeating advice usually comes from worry. But by the third time, it can sound like you don’t trust him to have heard you the first time.
Say it once, clearly: “I’ve said my piece. It’s your call.” If they want to talk it through again, let them bring it up.
5. Checking whether they took it
“So, did you call the plumber I mentioned?” “Did you ever talk to HR like I said?”
Following up can feel like caring. But when every piece of advice comes with a progress check, asking you can start to feel like taking on homework.
If you’re curious how things turned out, ask about the situation, not your suggestion: “How did it go with the leak?” Let them tell you what they decided, if they want to.
6. Taking it personally when they don’t follow it
Your daughter asked your opinion on the job offer, then took the other one. “Well, I don’t know why you bother asking me.”
It’s disappointing when you’ve given something real thought and it goes unused. But advice is input, not instructions. Adults ask several people and then decide.
Try: “I hope it’s a great fit. Tell me how the first week goes.” That makes it easier for her to ask again, even after she didn’t take your advice this time.
7. Bringing it up later, in front of others
At Thanksgiving, someone mentions your son’s car trouble. You say, “Well, I did tell him not to buy it.”
It might be meant as a joke. But it turns private advice into a public scoreboard, and next time, he may think twice before bringing you a problem.
Keep advice between the two of you, whether it was taken or not. If you’ve already let something slip, name it and say what you’ll do differently: “I’m sorry I brought up the car at dinner. You told me about it privately. I’ll leave it to you to bring up next time.”
Where to start
You don’t have to give up having opinions. The aim is to make asking feel easy and low-risk.
Picture the daycare call going differently. Your daughter says she can’t decide. You say, “Okay, what do you like about each one?” Then you listen to the whole answer.
When she’s done, you might say, “It sounds like the shorter commute would make mornings easier. How much does that matter to you?” She does most of the thinking. You help her hear it. And the next time she’s stuck, calling you may feel like an easy choice.
If you recognize yourself in a few of these habits, it’s okay to say so: “I gave you a lot of opinions last time. If you ever want my take again, I’ll keep it shorter.”