“I love you all the same.” Most parents of more than one child have said some version of that sentence, and they usually mean it. Their grown children are not always so sure. Sometimes one of them can still name who got the softer voice, the later curfew, the benefit of the doubt.

A 2025 review in Psychological Bulletin set out to see which kinds of children tend to be favored over their siblings, and its central finding is about daughters. What is easy to miss is where that finding came from. The lean toward daughters showed up in what parents said about their own parenting. In what children reported, it did not appear.

The review, by Alexander Jensen of Brigham Young University and McKell Jorgensen-Wells of Western University, pooled 30 journal articles, dissertations and theses with 14 other datasets, covering 19,469 people with an average age of about 20. Every comparison was between siblings in the same family. Some studies asked about favoritism outright; most measured concrete things: who got more warmth, who argued more with a parent, who received more privileges, time or money, and who was watched more closely.

The Artful Parent

Family-life ideas and sharp reads, in your inbox.

Was it the daughter?

Across the 16,290 people in the gender analysis, the first pass found no significant link between a child’s gender and how they were treated. The picture changed once the analysis separated who was doing the reporting.

When parents described their own parenting, daughters came out slightly ahead. When children described their households, there was no significant difference between sons and daughters. The researchers call the daughter effect small, and the word should travel with the finding. It also rests on the thinner slice of the evidence, since only about two in five of the pooled sources included parents’ accounts at all.

Picture how that might look at a holiday table. A mother is fairly sure she goes easier on her daughter, who rarely needs telling twice. Her son, asked whether either of them got special treatment, can’t think of any. Neither is lying; they are describing the same years from different chairs. That family is our illustration, not one from the study, and the review’s parent and child reports did not always come from the same households.

Why would parents describe something their children don’t? The researchers suggest one reason. Earlier research has found that girls score higher than boys, on average, on effortful control, the capacity to rein in an impulse, and that may make them easier to parent. Parents may sense that and recognize implicit differences in their own parenting, while explicit differences are rare enough that siblings may not notice them. Or, as the paper also puts it, parents’ and children’s perceptions may simply not match, even about the same experiences.

Earlier research never settled the gender question. Single studies disagreed, and some had found fathers favoring sons and mothers favoring daughters. This review did not reproduce that split: it made no significant difference whether the treatment being rated was a father’s or a mother’s. A large 2016 meta-analysis comparing parenting across families found no gender differences in parenting, except that studies published since 1990 showed parents more supportive of girls’ autonomy than boys’, a result the authors describe as somewhat consistent with their own.

Who else came out ahead?

More conscientious children, the dependable, responsible ones, tended to receive slightly more favorable treatment: a little more warmth from parents and, more strongly, less conflict with them than their siblings had. More agreeable children had a very small edge as well.

Birth order was more tangled. Younger siblings looked slightly favored overall, but that edge disappeared once other factors were taken into account. What held was that older siblings tended to be controlled less and given more autonomy, a small-to-medium effect Jensen and Jorgensen-Wells connect to an older child’s greater readiness for freedom. They add that earlier studies tie that kind of uneven control, sensible or not, to lower self-worth and more behavior problems in the sibling on the other end of it.

Does it last into adulthood?

For readers whose children are long grown, this is the question that matters, and the review can say little about it. Of the sources behind the birth-order analysis, only five had participants averaging over 40, and those five came from just two samples. The clearest hint comes from the agreeableness analysis, where the small advantage did not differ significantly between childhood and adulthood. The authors write that parents tend to favor the same adult offspring as they did in childhood. We would give that line less weight than its phrasing invites: it rests on one very small effect, and in the fuller model even that estimate was no longer significant.

The other limits are plain ones. Every sample came from North America or Western Europe, only English-language studies were included, and the effects were mostly small. And though the paper does not dwell on it, the review is built entirely on correlations. It is framed around children’s traits drawing out different treatment, but correlations cannot rule out the reverse, that the treatment shapes the child, or both at once.

Was it fair?

The researchers call one piece of this critical, and it is the one they could not measure. Earlier work by Kowal and colleagues, which the review cites, found that whether a difference in treatment is seen as fair is essential to how it lands. A younger child kept on a shorter leash may shrug if the reason is obvious and may not if it isn’t. Too few studies have measured fairness for it to be pooled, so this review could not test it.

Being the less-favored sibling has been linked in earlier research to poorer mental health and more strained family relationships, though those links are associations as well. If an old sense of being the second-choice child still shapes how you get along with a parent or a sibling, a family therapist or counselor can work through it with you. This piece reports one review, checked against the full paper, and cannot sort out any single family’s history.

The researchers call for more work on favoritism in mid to later life and beyond North America and Western Europe. When grown siblings compare notes about the shorter leash or the softer voice, how many of them were ever told the reason?