A toddler can ask for the same board book three times before breakfast. To the adult reading it, the words may feel thoroughly worn out. In the Ohio State researchers’ calculation, those repeated readings still count.

Their 2019 estimate was that a child who is read five books a day will have heard 1,483,300 words from books by their fifth birthday. A child who is almost never read to will have heard 4,662.

The paper, published in the Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, rounds the difference to 1.4 million words and gives it a name: the million word gap. (Subtract one figure from the other and you land closer to 1.48 million.)

The Artful Parent

Family-life ideas and sharp reads, in your inbox.

These are total words heard during book reading, including repeated words and repeated books, not 1.4 million different vocabulary words.

How the estimate was built

No children were tested for this study, and nobody sat in living rooms with a clicker. It is a calculation, and a fairly simple one.

The Columbus Metropolitan Library gave the team its lists of the 100 most borrowed board books and the 100 most borrowed picture books. The researchers pulled 30 titles at random from each list and counted the words. Board books averaged 140. Picture books, which are aimed at preschoolers, averaged 228. After removing unusually long books, the researchers used median lengths of 129 words for board books and 214 for picture books to calculate the totals.

Then came the assumptions. A child hears board books until age 3 and picture books for the two years after that. Each sitting covers one book. Families who say they never read are still credited with one book every other month.

From there it is multiplication. By age 5, the totals come out as:

  • Almost never read to: 4,662 words
  • Once or twice a week: 63,570 words
  • Three to five times a week: 169,520 words
  • One book every day: 296,660 words
  • Five books every day: 1,483,300 words

What the headline figure hides

Five books a day is the top row of the table, and it is exactly five times the daily row because that is how it was worked out. Nothing in the study points to a threshold at five, or says the fifth book does something the first one doesn’t.

For most households the more useful comparison sits lower down. One book a day adds up to roughly 290,000 more words than the child who is almost never read to. It is also more than four times the total for a child who hears a book once or twice a week.

And because the method counts words heard at each sitting, the fortieth reading of the same truck book counts exactly as much as the first.

Why book words get their own count

Lead author Jessica Logan’s argument is that the language in children’s books is not the language of the kitchen. Books tend to use harder and more varied words than everyday talk at home. Her example was a picture book about penguins in Antarctica, which hands a three-year-old vocabulary that is unlikely to come up over breakfast.

Her reasoning is that children who have already heard those words are better placed to recognize them in print once school starts. She also thinks the estimate runs low, since adults rarely read a book straight through. They stop, point, answer questions and add their own commentary, and none of that talk was counted.

This is a separate measure from the older and much-argued claim that children in poverty hear 30 million fewer words in conversation by age 3. Logan noted that later studies suggest that gap may be far smaller, or may not exist at all.

What the study can’t tell you

It counts words heard, not words learned. The authors present the gap as one possible piece of the explanation for differences in vocabulary and early reading. They did not follow children to see who read sooner.

The word counts come from 60 books on one Ohio library system’s most-borrowed lists. A different shelf would give somewhat different averages.

The calculation holds reading frequency steady across five years. Real routines change: a baby becomes a toddler, work schedules shift, and some weeks contain more reading than others.

The project grew out of Logan’s earlier work on a national sample, which found that about a quarter of children were never read to and another quarter were read to only once or twice a week. She called those numbers “pretty shocking.” The estimate was a way of putting a size on what that might mean, not a scorecard for parents.

The small version

The books in the study were not special. They were the ones most often checked out of a public library, which means a library card gets you the same shelf for free.

If five a day sounds like someone else’s life, look at the middle of the table. Going from a couple of books a week to one a day is a step many families can manage.

Put a familiar book beside the place you already sit together. Offer it after breakfast or before bed. If your child stops you to talk about the dog in the picture, follow that conversation. You don’t have to hurry to the last page.