If your children have left home, you have probably heard the gloomy line from research on parenthood. Children, it goes, do not make people happier, and parents can even come out behind people who never had them. Many studies have reported a negative link of that kind, as the authors of a 2019 European analysis point out.

Their own numbers, from people aged 50 and older, add a later chapter. Across more than 50,000 adults in 16 countries, parents of two children were slightly more satisfied with life than people without children. The researchers trace that positive link to children who had already left home, while each child still living with a parent pointed the other way. Christoph Becker, Isadora Kirchmaier and Stefan Trautmann, researchers at Heidelberg University’s Alfred-Weber-Institute for Economics, set out the findings in the open-access journal PLOS ONE.

The survey behind it

The data come from SHARE, the Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe, which interviews people aged 50 and older. This study used its fourth round, carried out from 2010 to 2012 in 16 countries stretching from Sweden and Estonia to Spain and Portugal, and left out people living in nursing homes. Seven in ten respondents were married or in a registered partnership, and 91 percent had children.

The Artful Parent

Family-life ideas and sharp reads, in your inbox.

Respondents rated how satisfied they were with their life on a scale from 0 to 10. They also answered questions about quality of life, covering control, autonomy, pleasure and a sense of self-realization. They said how satisfied they were with the people around them, and they went through a checklist of depression symptoms, from sadness and poor sleep to irritability and loss of interest.

Children at home and children gone

Besides comparing parents with people who had no children, the researchers recorded how many children still lived in each household. That let them separate children at home from children who had left.

Taken at face value, people with two children rated their lives a quarter of a point higher than people without children, 7.64 against 7.39 out of 10. Holding constant the number of children still at home, along with age, sex, country, marriage and the number of grandchildren, the gap for two children was about 0.18 points. With income, education, health, work and other background factors also counted, it shrank to about 0.11.

Each child still at home went the other way, with slightly lower life satisfaction and a quality-of-life score about a tenth of a point lower. Two children were also linked to slightly fewer depression symptoms, while, once income, health and the other background factors were counted, each child at home came with slightly more.

The overall positive association, the authors write, is “due to children after they left home.”

They describe the pattern as very similar for men and women, though some details differed; among men, children at home were tied only to the quality-of-life score. As the strain of juggling child care, work and the rest of life eases and grown children leave, the authors suggest, “the importance of children as caregivers and social contacts might prevail.” The survey offers a hint in that direction. When respondents named the people they discuss important matters with, their lists were, on average, about one-third children, roughly the same share as partners.

The size of the difference

In the same models, rating one’s own health as excellent rather than poor was tied to about two more points of life satisfaction, and being married to about half a point. Two children, by comparison, came to a tenth or two.

Parents of one child were no more satisfied with life than people without children, and the edge for three or more children faded once income, education and health were accounted for. Run country by country, the results did not change in kind, the authors say, though many individual results were not statistically significant.

Each additional grandchild came with very slightly higher satisfaction with one’s social circle and, in the fuller models, with life. In the simpler models, more grandchildren went with a lower quality-of-life score and more depressive symptoms, links that disappeared in the fuller ones. The survey holds too little about grandchildren, not even whether they live in the same home, for the authors to explain the split.

A single snapshot

This was one round of interviews comparing different people at one moment, so it cannot show that anyone grew more satisfied when a child moved out. Nor can it say why some people 50 and older still had children at home, whether by choice, for financial reasons or because someone needed care. The authors call the results “correlational in nature” and say data that follow the same people over time are needed to separate cause from coincidence.

The survey measured satisfaction with life, not everyday good and bad feelings, so it says little about happiness from one moment to the next. Even the head count needs a footnote: the paper describes about 55,000 people, its country table adds up to 52,513, and the analyses of all respondents drew on between about 44,000 and 52,500 of them, with the separate analyses of men and of women smaller still.

We are reporting on a study here, not assessing readers. Sadness, poor sleep and loss of interest, all on the survey’s depression checklist, are among the things a doctor or counselor asks about. If they have lasted for weeks since the house went quiet, that is reason enough to book an appointment now rather than wait for the next visit home.

For people without children, the study’s network findings are the ones to read. Every kind of personal network the researchers identified, including circles made up mostly of friends, was linked to higher life satisfaction and more satisfaction with one’s social circle than having no one to confide in.

After the holiday

Among people who named someone to confide in, being in touch more often and feeling closer to those people were linked to higher scores on every measure. Those models also held network size, network type and family status equal. In them, living nearer to the same people, once contact and closeness were accounted for, went with slightly lower scores on most measures.

For many families, Thanksgiving next week brings grown children back to the table, beds made up in old rooms and a noisier house for a few days. Then the house goes quiet again. In this survey, how often people stayed in touch went along with higher well-being; how close they lived did not.