8 signs someone isn’t a good parent (even if they seem competent on the surface)

by Allison Price
October 22, 2025

It’s easy to assume that a good parent is the one who always remembers the permission slips.

The one who packs balanced lunches, shows up early to practice, and posts smiling family photos.

From the outside, everything looks steady and successful.

But parenting is so much more than what we can see from the surface.

Competence is helpful, but it’s not the same thing as connection.

A parent can run a household like clockwork and still miss what their child’s heart is quietly trying to say.

I’ve met parents who seem calm and organized, yet their kids carry a loneliness that no one talks about.

I’ve also been that parent, holding everything together so tightly that I forgot to pause and notice what my children were actually feeling.

If you’ve ever wondered whether someone, or maybe even you, might be missing the deeper parts of parenting, here are eight quiet signs to pay attention to.

These are not about judgment or shame.

They are invitations to look beneath the surface, to soften, to listen, and to choose love over control.

1. Everything looks calm, but there’s no real connection

Some homes run like well-oiled machines.

The laundry is done, meals appear on time, and routines are followed without a fuss.

From the outside, it looks like a picture of stability.

But inside, there might be a quiet distance between parent and child.

The house is calm, but it’s the kind of calm that feels like silence, not peace.

When parenting becomes mostly about managing tasks, children can start to feel unseen.

They might stop sharing their thoughts because they sense no one is really listening.

They might behave perfectly but feel emotionally invisible.

Connection doesn’t live in the rules or the routines.

It lives in the small moments when we pause long enough to really look at our child and say, “Tell me more about that.”

Try sitting beside your child without an agenda.

Let them talk about something that doesn’t seem important.

That’s often where the connection begins again.

2. Rules are clear, but choices are rare

Rules give kids structure and safety, but when everything becomes about control, children stop learning how to think for themselves.

A parent who relies too much on “because I said so” might keep short-term order but lose long-term trust.

Kids thrive when they have a voice.

They don’t need to be in charge, but they do need to feel heard.

When they get to help make decisions, even small ones, they learn responsibility instead of rebellion.

Instead of demanding, “You have to do it this way,” try asking, “What might make this easier for you next time?”

That shift changes the tone from power to partnership.

It says, “I trust you enough to be part of the solution.”

When children feel that kind of trust, they often rise to meet it.

3. Achievement gets more attention than empathy

A child who grows up constantly praised for success but not supported through struggle learns that love has conditions.

They start believing they have to earn it.

That belief might push them to perform, but it also quietly drains their sense of self-worth.

I’ve seen children who always smile in photos and bring home great grades, yet flinch when they make a mistake.

They’re terrified of disappointing the adults who seem so proud of them.

As parents, we all want our kids to do well.

But the deeper goal is for them to feel safe being imperfect.

When your child stumbles, how do you respond?

Do you sigh, or do you say, “That was tough. I’m here. Let’s figure it out.”

Empathy is the soil where confidence grows.

Without it, even success starts to feel hollow.

4. The parent never shows vulnerability

Some parents believe their job is to be endlessly strong.

They think showing weakness might confuse their child or make them lose respect.

But the truth is, pretending to have it all together builds a wall, not safety.

Kids need to see that adults make mistakes and recover.

They learn how to handle failure by watching us handle ours.

If we never admit when we’re wrong, they learn that mistakes are something to hide.

When we say, “I was impatient earlier. I’m sorry,” we teach them that love can stretch and repair.

It also gives them permission to do the same when they mess up.

Perfection might impress a child for a while, but honesty earns their trust forever.

5. Helping turns into control

Every parent wants to help.

We jump in to tie the shoe, fix the friendship, or rewrite the school project.

It’s natural to want to protect our children from struggle.

But when we do everything for them, we take away their chance to learn resilience.

Struggle isn’t failure.

It’s the training ground for confidence.

Letting a child wrestle with frustration can feel uncomfortable, but it’s one of the kindest things we can do.

Pause before stepping in.

Ask yourself, “Is my help needed, or am I just uncomfortable watching them try?”

Sometimes a child needs space to figure things out.

Offer encouragement from the sidelines instead of constant direction.

It’s a slower kind of parenting, but it raises stronger, more capable kids.

6. Feelings are managed instead of met

A parent might say, “You’re fine,” or “Stop crying,” with the best intentions.

We want to calm our kids down, not make things worse.

But when we skip over their feelings, they learn to hide them.

They stop expressing sadness, anger, or fear because it seems unwanted.

Real connection means welcoming emotions, not silencing them.

Try sitting with your child and saying, “I see you’re sad. That makes sense. I’m here.”

You don’t have to fix it.

Just be steady and kind.

That presence teaches them that big feelings are survivable.

They learn that emotions can come and go without shame.

A calm moment of empathy can do more than any lecture ever could.

7. Boundaries are for the child, not the parent

We tell kids to eat healthy food, go to bed on time, and take breaks from screens.

But how often do we follow those same rules ourselves?

Children watch us far more closely than they listen to us.

When they see us scrolling at midnight or skipping meals, they learn that boundaries are flexible and optional.

Modeling self-care is one of the strongest forms of teaching.

It tells a child, “This is how we take care of a body and a mind.”

Ask yourself: What boundary could I hold better to show my child how to respect themselves?

Maybe it’s turning off your phone at dinner.

Maybe it’s taking a real rest instead of powering through.

The example you live is the lesson they keep.

8. Everything looks stable, but the parent is quietly falling apart

Some families look picture-perfect from the outside.

The house is spotless.

The routines are in place.

The smiles look effortless.

But inside, the parent is exhausted, lonely, or overwhelmed.

Children feel that energy even when no one talks about it.

They pick up on the quiet tension in the air.

Taking care of yourself isn’t selfish.

It’s part of taking care of them.

When you’re depleted, patience fades, joy fades, and everything becomes heavier.

Ask yourself: What support do I need right now?

Maybe it’s rest.

Maybe it’s someone to talk to.

Maybe it’s admitting that you can’t do everything alone.

Your wellbeing sets the tone for your child’s emotional safety.

You matter just as much as they do.

Closing thoughts

Noticing these signs isn’t about blame.

It’s about awareness and grace.

Every parent slips into these habits sometimes.

We all have days when we’re too tired to connect or too focused on control.

What matters is noticing the drift and gently finding our way back.

Parenting isn’t about perfection.

It’s about presence.

It’s about being brave enough to admit when we’re struggling and kind enough to keep trying.

Choose one of these signs that feels familiar to you.

Think about what small change might bring more connection into your home this week.

Maybe it’s pausing for a five-minute talk before bedtime.

Maybe it’s letting your child take the lead in a small decision.

Maybe it’s saying “I’m sorry” and meaning it.

You don’t need to fix everything at once.

You just need to notice, to care, and to keep learning.

I’ve been there too.

I’m still learning every single day.

And that’s exactly what good parents do.

 

What is Your Inner Child's Artist Type?

Knowing your inner child’s artist type can be deeply beneficial on several levels, because it reconnects you with the spontaneous, unfiltered part of yourself that first experienced creativity before rules, expectations, or external judgments came in. This 90-second quiz reveals your unique creative blueprint—the way your inner child naturally expresses joy, imagination, and originality. In just a couple of clicks, you’ll uncover the hidden strengths that make you most alive… and learn how to reignite that spark right now.

 
    Shop our Favorite Supplies!
    Visit our YouTube channel!
    Shop Printables
    Shop our Favorite Supplies!
    Print
    Share
    Pin